This is an extended passage is from Edmund Burke's 1757 treatise entitled A Philosophical Enquiry into the Origin of our Ideas of the Sublime and Beautiful. Burke (who is famous for his essay that criticized the French Revolution, which displayed his intellectual conservatism) is in this work contemplating aesthetics and contemplating the psychology of the "sublime"—or, the intensity of emotion that one experiences in response to some works of art or literature. In this passage, Burke challenges the notion that we are spellbound by tragedies (like those of Shakespeare, for example), because we know that they are artificial. He argues instead that the more authentic tragedies are the more we are affected by them:
The nearer it approaches the reality, and the further it removes us from all idea of fiction, the more perfect is its power. But be its power of what kind it will, it never approaches to what it represents.
He points out that people are captivated by real-life tragedies and horror, which explains why people used to turn out in droves to witness public executions and why people are still fascinated by catastrophes like deadly fires and earthquakes. Burke attributes this to our sympathy for the victims, which he argues is rooted in the understanding that these horrible things could happen to us. We are moved by tragedies—Burke even says we "delight" in them—at a safe distance.
In the chapter preceding the quote in this question, Burke posits that this is an instinct; it is something that is innate and fundamental to the human condition—and thus prior to reason. He claims that this instinct has the same origins as sympathy. By "sympathy," he refers to what many eighteenth-century writers called "fellow-feeling," or the idea that one could identify with the suffering (and the pleasures) of others.
It is important to remember that Burke's purpose in all of this is to explain why we are drawn to certain works of art and literature. He is often considered a Romantic writer in this sense, because he focuses on the ability of art to bring out innate (even instinctual) responses in readers and viewers. He describes this as the "sublime," which encompasses feelings of horror, revulsion, and even sympathy.
Therefore, this passage is attempting to explain why it is that we are so drawn to tragedy, and Burke's answer is that tragedy (the more authentic, the more powerful) evokes sublime emotions.
https://wordsworth.org.uk/blog/2015/03/02/edmund-burke-and-the-sublime/
https://www.bartleby.com/24/2/114.html
No comments:
Post a Comment