Wednesday, January 2, 2013

Compare how women are depicted in Beowulf, Sir Gawain and the Green Knight, and Chaucer's "The Wife of Bath's Tale."

The three texts mentioned present women quite differently, in part due to their genre and in part due to their historical context.
Epics tend to dwell on male interests, with women presented as obstacles to the male hero's destiny. In Beowulf, we see women as tokens exchanged in marriage or as givers of gifts initiated by their husbands. One could take the passages dealing with women out of the text and retain almost every important element.
Sir Gawain is medieval romance. Some suggest that Eleanor of Aquitaine fostered a love of romance in her court (and beyond) as a covert way of presenting an alternative type of power to the male feudal system. In romance, the more feminine courtly code is opposed to the militaristic chivalric code. In this poem, Gawain is placed in a position where he must uphold courtly codes and hospitality with the castle's mistress, Lady Bertilak, while her husband goes out to hunt. The challenges he confronts successfully help define his heroism every bit a much as killing in battle might.
In this poem, women also have an alternative power that extends beyond their control in domestic or romantic affairs: they also have access to magic. Morgan le Fay appears in this story, as she so often does, to create an alternative not available to typical male figures. In fact, at the end of the poem, we see that Morgan seems to have masterminded the entire plot as one of her customary attempts to weaken Arthur's court and harm his reputation.
In The Canterbury Tales, accusations of sorcery are among the many misogynistic claims Chaucer's Wife of Bath confronts. In her tale, the woman is able to work magic, providing a type of wish fulfillment for the rapist knight. However, the important element in Chaucer's presentation of the Wife is her obvious intelligence, her business acumen, her keen understanding (even at 12) of the way in which women are made to be commodities in the feudal marriage system, and her resistance to how the Church "mis-treats" women in Biblical texts.
The Wife's prologue—which is an Apologia of her life in marriage and a witty refutation of Church teachings on gender—browbeats the pilgrims in such a way that Harry Bailey finally insists that they let her speak. Her prologue seems designed to carve out a space in which her voice refuses to be silenced by the more argumentative male pilgrims.
The same happens when the rapist knight is complaining about marrying an old and ugly woman, even though he promised he would if she saved his life. Through intelligence and rhetorical finesse, the Wife works her own magic and gains the upper hand.

No comments:

Post a Comment

What is the theme of the chapter Lead?

Primo Levi's complex probing of the Holocaust, including his survival of Auschwitz and pre- and post-war life, is organized around indiv...