Wednesday, June 20, 2018

On what page of Cutting for Stone is the question "What first-aid treatment in shock is administered by ear?"

Page numbers differ between editions, but it is within chapter 2, "The Missing Finger," that the surgeon Dr. Thomas Stone reminisces about a question posed by an instructor he had in medical school.*

“What first-aid treatment in shock is administered by ear?” His answer, “Words of comfort!” had won the day.

The memory comes to him during a scene in which Sister Mary Joseph Praise, a nun, nurse, and coworker at Missing Hospital in Ethiopia, has to undergo an emergency cesarean section. It is Dr. Stone who finds Sister Praise in her room, where she “lay in agony,” her pulse “rapid and feeble.” He kneels beside her bed, struggling to understand why he, a doctor, is overcome with such strong emotions. A surgeon must have, above all, steady hands. Here, we see Dr. Stone reach for Sister Praise’s face with “an old man’s palsy.” The man commonly perceived as distant and cold has realized he loves this woman. His astonishment registers both emotionally and physically.
Dr. Stone’s eyes finally fall upon Sister Praise’s swollen abdomen. He is unable to believe that the nun could be pregnant, despite every indication that she is. He carries her to the operating theater, convinced she is suffering from a bowel obstruction. He thinks of his instructor’s question and his own response, words of comfort, but he is unable to summon any. Instead, Dr. Stone shouts for help.
*The quote appears on page 44 within the Kindle edition and could be expected to come within a few pages in other formats.
Verghese, Abraham. Cutting for Stone. Vintage Books, 2010.

How does the story reflect issues in the author’s life?

Herman Melville was required to take on many mundane jobs, as his career as an author failed to ever launch him into much success during his lifetime. The character of Bartleby, however, does more than represent a working-class everyman. Bartleby reflects Melville's deeper spiritual issues regarding the value of work and life. While the other characters in Bartleby the Scrivener accept their lot in life, Bartleby does not. The simple expression "I prefer not to" reflects a denial of any activity that simply preoccupies one in life as they await death.
Melville struggled with what many, and probably Melville himself, would see as a nihilistic perspective on existence. The character of the lawyer acts as a conscience to this dire point of view presented by Bartleby. Possibly, this is Melville's argument against these leanings in his own personal outlook. For the lawyer puts up with Bartleby at every turn as if dealing with an undesirable part of himself.
In the end, the final cry from the lawyer at Bartleby's death is "Ah humanity!" Melville expresses this unresolved conflict in himself and the world between plodding through existence or denying it.

Tuesday, June 19, 2018

What are the main themes of Kafka's Letter to His Father?

Kafka wrote a lengthy letter to his father, initially as an attempt to begin reconciliation with him—the man who had caused him immense trauma as a child. Kafka's father was abusive and narcissistic—aggressively punishing and harming him for many years. This abuse haunted Kafka for the rest of his life, but in his adulthood, he decided that he wanted to try and have a fresh start and forgive his father.
Following a train of thought like most letters do, however, it quickly devolved into anger and bitterness—with Kafka railing at his father for the emotional damage he caused him. The themes in this work, clearly, are bitterness and suffering—as well as the idea of forgiveness, which was attempted, but mainly, in the end, was a critical reaction to his father's actions.


Franz Kafka wrote a set of letters to his abusive and heavily narcissistic father. The letter was initially an attempt to reconcile with the man who had caused him so much trauma, but it quickly morphed. He spends much of the 47-page letter analyzing his relationship with his father and discussing the reasons why he fears him. He is broken because of the abuse and trauma he suffered at his father’s hands.
The theme of this letter is the criticism of his father’s actions. It is clear that Kafka understands the vital role a father plays in his child’s development and future confidence, since he spends so long decrying the pain and torment through which his father put him. He goes through a long-winded, winding train of thought sequence, bringing up all the painful events he experienced as a result of his father, just to drive the point home.


The theme of Franz Kafka's letter to his father is dysfunctional relationships between fathers and sons.
Kafka starts out by acknowledging that he is afraid of his father. His explanation of fear—the way Kafka could not think of an immediate answer to justify his fear of his father—will resonate with anybody who has experienced fear of a parent.
Later in the letter, Kafka points out that his father had been too strong, which is indicative of a lifelong struggle for father and son to see eye to eye. It seems that in attempting to raise Kafka to be strong and brave, Kafka's father failed to show his son any of the kindheartedness that he did, inherently, have.
The conclusion of the letter states that Kafka has a significant lack of trust in himself. That mistrust, according to Kafka, was fostered by his father.


Known as Letter to His Father, the forty-seven-and-a-half-page letter author Franz Kafka wrote to his father in November 1919 became part of his overall literary body of work. The letter was published in 1966 in book form. The themes of the letter are very straightforward and clear, such as the tumultuous relationship Franz Kafka had with his father.
One of the most prominent themes is Kafka's criticism of his emotionally abusive father. Initially, Kafka thought the letter would heal their troubled relationship, but instead Kafka goes into lengthy detail as to why he is afraid of his father. The letter is inherently stream of consciousness in style, as most personal letters are, and it offers a view of not only Kafka's relationship with his father but also of his psychological makeup.
The letter is considered significant—along with his other correspondences, such as those to Milena Jesenská—by literary critics because it showed the personal basis for many of the themes found in Kafka's work, such as identity crises, self-loathing, troubled relationships, abandonment, and hopelessness.

How does the story "The Gift of the Magi" show the overall theme "love is greater than material possessions"?

Jim and Della have a very close, loving relationship. And with Christmas just around the corner they want to express their love through the exchange of gifts. Jim buys Della some combs for her pretty hair, and Della buys Jim a chain for his pocket-watch. Unfortunately, Jim and Della are dirt poor and don't have a lot of money to spend on gifts. The only way that Della can afford to buy Jim's gift is by selling some of her beautiful locks to a fancy wig-maker. And the only way that Jim can afford to buy Della's gift is by selling his pocket-watch.
Both Jim and Della have ended up with what are, from a practical standpoint, worthless gifts. But they're so much more than that. The combs and the watch-chain are expressions of the deep love that Jim and Della have for each other. It makes no difference that they have no practical use-value; what matters is the loving thoughtfulness that went into choosing each gift.

In Hemingway's "The Snows of Kilimanjaro," what purpose do you think the flashbacks serve? Why does Harry pretend to hate Helen (or does he truly hate her)? How does Harry show the signs of a man recovering from having been in bloody combat in World War I, and does that add an extra level of meaning to the story? You may also consider any examples of irony in the short story.

The flashbacks in "The Snows of Kilimanjaro" show how Harry, dying of an infected leg wound in Africa, mentally processes the fact that he is going to die, and the effect of that realization on his consciousness. The flashbacks, indicated in the story by italic print, are part of Harry's reflection on his life and how he lived it. In the flashback sections, Harry frequently expresses regret that he did not write more often: "He knew at least twenty good stories from out there and he had never written one. Why?" Through the flashbacks, the readers see Harry gradually come to terms with his situation.
In the final flashback scene, just before he dies, Harry remembers an officer from his time in World War I who was struck by a German bomb and begged to be shot. He recalls an argument "about our Lord never sending you anything you could not bear and someone's theory had been that meant that at a certain time the pain passed you out automatically." After he breaks from this reverie, he tells his wife, Helen, "I've been writing." He has achieved, in his mind, what he had been trying to do: reconcile his life, and his choices, with present reality. He is at peace and ready to die. It's ironic that Harry's final flashback involves war and guns. At the beginning of "Snows," Harry suggests, bitterly, that Helen could shoot him. "You're a good shot now. I taught you how to shoot, didn't I?" he tells her. But in the flashback, he does not shoot the officer, instead offering him morpheme tablets to handle the pain.
In my opinion Harry does not hate Helen; he hates himself and some of the life choices he has made. His resentment seeps out in several caustic remarks directed at Helen, who comes from an upper-class family. "If you hadn't left your own people," Harry tells her, "your goddamned Old Westbury, Saratoga, Palm Beach people to take me on—". Ironically, Harry later realizes that he has become one of those people: "each day of not writing, of comfort, of being that which he despised, dulled his ability and softened his will to work so that, finally, he did no work at all." This is the beginning of a turning point for Harry. He begins to unmask his self-deception and to come to terms with the life he and Helen have created. They eventually share a drink at the campfire, and Harry "could feel the return of acquiescence in this life of pleasant surrender. She was very good to him. He had been cruel and unjust in the afternoon. She was a fine woman, marvellous really."
Many of Harry's flashbacks deal with his time at war, but these focus mostly not on fighting but on people and places Harry remembers and stories that he wanted to write about them. "He had seen the world change; not just the events; although he had seen many of them and had watched the people, but he had seen the subtler change and he could remember how the people were at different times." He had wanted to write it, but now he couldn't. At first he was bitter, but, partially by reliving the best of his life through flashbacks and analyzing it, Harry is able to reconcile his past and present. By the end, he is prepared for the final journey.

Why does the poet describe the earth as "secret"?

The speaker is referring to the natural dwelling-place of the snake. He slithers out of his home in a black hole to drink at the water trough, which is where he encounters the speaker, standing there in his pajamas, waiting to fill his pitcher. The black hole is described as a "dark door," the dark door of the "secret earth." The snake's home is secret because it's a part of the earth that humans seldom get to see. It's a dark, cavernous place that leads to the depths of the earth. The contrast between the snake's natural habitat and the human world above really couldn't be more stark. Above ground, all is visible; all is clear. But the same cannot be said for the subterranean world inhabited by the snake. There, all is dark and mysterious, and the secrets of this world wait to be discovered by man.
https://www.poetsgraves.co.uk/Classic%20Poems/Lawrence/snake.htm

What are the similarities between Louise Mallard in Chopin's "A Story of an Hour" and one of the three main characters in Walker's "Everyday Use."

In "Story of an Hour," Mrs. Mallard is upset when she initially hears of her husband's presumed death in a railroad accident. However, as she begins to think about her husband, she can't decide whether she had loved him or not. She feels ambivalent towards him, but she knows that she is happy to be living on her own.
Mrs. Mallard is similar to Mama in "Everyday Use." While she loves Dee in some ways, as Dee is her daughter, she is happy to live apart from her. Dee looks down on Mama and tends to lecture her and to act superior to her. At the end of the story, Mama refuses to give Dee the quilts she wants, and she decides to give them to her other daughter, Maggie. Mama's decision to withhold the quilts from Dee symbolizes Mama's withholding her true love from Dee. Like Louise Mallard, Mama at some point decides to free herself from her controlling daughter and to live without her.

What is the theme of the chapter Lead?

Primo Levi's complex probing of the Holocaust, including his survival of Auschwitz and pre- and post-war life, is organized around indiv...