Both stories deal with power relationships between colonizer and the colonized. In the Orwell story, the "revelation" is that the Burmese are the ones who wield the true power; as a "sahib," Orwell must do what is expected of a sahib, whatever his personal inclinations might be. As he says in the conclusion of the story, he did what he did to "avoid looking the fool."
In the Lessing story, Gideon also possesses power over his colonial masters, in the form of his knowledge of medicinal plants. His decision to not share the secret of the root he used to save Teddy's vision with the white doctor is based on a desire to protect the knowledge of his people from appropriation and commodification.
In the same way that Orwell is grateful that the elephant killed a person, in that it gave legal justification for his decision to shoot it, there is a sense that Gideon is grateful to be known as just "the boy in the kitchen" rather than the son of a famous witch doctor. In both cases, their respective roles as master and servant allow them to preserve some core value: in Orwell's case, his dignity, and in Gideon's case, his identity.
Thursday, April 9, 2015
Compare and contrast the conflicts faced by Orwell in “Shooting an Elephant” to those faced by Gideon in “No Witchcraft for Sale.” To what unique revelation does Orwell’s position as a police officer lead him? How can Gideon’s ultimate decision not to share his knowledge be interpreted as an act of rebellion and an assertion of the dignity and worth of his culture?
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
What is the theme of the chapter Lead?
Primo Levi's complex probing of the Holocaust, including his survival of Auschwitz and pre- and post-war life, is organized around indiv...
-
Bacteria are single-celled microorganisms that thrive in diverse environments (such as the ocean, the soil, and the human body). Various bac...
-
Note that these events are not in chronological order. The story is told by the narrator, looking back upon her life. The first notable even...
-
It seems most likely you are asking about Michael Halliday's theories of language. He argues children have seven main functions they use...
-
Under common law, any hotel, inn, or other hospitality establishment has a duty to exercise "reasonable care" for the safety an...
-
Samuel Taylor Coleridge’s long narrative poem "Christabel" presents the well-known theme of good vs. evil, but the poem ends with ...
-
The tension between the three world orders after World War II (1939–1945) manifested itself in territorial, economic, military, ideologic...
-
Grover Cleveland is known as a reformer. The first Democrat elected after the Civil War, Cleveland has the distinction of being the only Pre...
No comments:
Post a Comment